
It drives my kids crazy when I correct their text messages. They text yell, “it’s just a text”, but I know if they are using too/two and there/their incorrectly in a text, they are probably using it incorrectly all the time.
I’m their mom, it’s my right/write. Too many nuances in the English language!
Another realm where there are TOO many rules is surrounding Roth IRAs and in particular, the TWO “5-year rules” related to Roth IRA accounts.
When it comes to Roth IRAs, there are TWO ways they can be funded and TWO “5-year rules” that must be differentiated when it comes to distributions from the IRA.
Generally speaking, I most often discuss Roth CONTRIBUTIONS with clients still in their wealth building years and Roth CONVERSIONS with clients who are nearing or in retirement.
But this is not always the case, as I had a Roth conversion discussion last week with a younger client because for her, it may make sense to do a conversion now.
And a back door Roth, which I speak with clients about often, is a contribution/conversion combo.
First, some differences between the two ways a Roth can be funded:
*Contribution amounts are limited each year by the IRS ($6,500 in 2023 with a $1,000 over 50 catch up)
*Contributions are made with after-tax dollars.
*If you earn too much (according to the IRS), your contributions may be phased out, or you may not be able to directly contribute to a Roth IRA at all.
*Your CONTRIBUTIONS can be withdrawn at any time, penalty free (but the goal is to keep them in!)
Roth CONVERSIONS
*Conversions are not limited by amounts or income levels. You can convert as much or as little as you want at any time, regardless of how much you earn (this is the rule that allows for the back door Roth strategy).
*Conversions are typically made from an IRA. You are converting from a “pre-tax money” account to an “after tax money” account (with a few caveats, like in the case of a non-deductible IRA).
*Since you are converting pre-tax dollars, you must pay taxes on the amount being converted in the year it is converted.
Moving on to the TWO 5-Year Rules:
5-Year Rule #1 – Pertains to Growth only (for both contributions or conversions)
- For the GROWTH in your Roth IRA to become what is called a QUALIFIED DISTRIBUTION (tax and penalty free distribution), two conditions must be met:
- 5-Year Rule #1 – the account must have been open for at least 5 tax years (there are favorable rules around when the clock starts on the 5-years).
AND
- The IRA owner must be 59.5 or older (or totally disabled; a few other exceptions exist)
- The “start clock” for the 5 year rule on GROWTH applies to the growth on all future contributions as well. In other words, you could put $1 into a Roth in 2023 to start the clock, even if you do not make another contribution until 2028. You will have satisfied the 5-Year rule to be able to withdraw the growth tax and penalty free (if you are 59.5 or older).
5-Year Rule #2 – Pertains to CONVERSION amounts
- The SECOND 5-year rule pertains to whether the amount you converted can be withdrawn penalty free. Unlike Roth CONTRIBUTIONS that can be taken back out penalty free at any time, you cannot pull your conversion amounts out before the 5-year clock is up,or you will pay a penalty on the withdrawal.
- Very Important: Unlike the 5-Year clock for new CONTRIBUTIONS discussed above, where the first contribution starts the clock, every CONVERSION has its own 5-year clock that begins with the tax year the conversion is made.
Note that when a client is 59.5 or older, Rule #2 becomes obsolete and there is NO penalty for withdrawal of the conversion principal.
But if they have not had a Roth account open for at least 5-years (Rule #1), then the clock starts in the year of conversion, so they cannot withdraw the growth tax and penalty free until that requirement is met.
Ultimately, the two 5-year rules surrounding Roth IRAs, while seemingly complicated, exist to keep the “spirit of the law” in place and to prevent misuse of this type of tax advantaged account.
But when managed effectively, and in the right situations, Roth contributions and conversions can offer great planning opportunities for many clients.













